Trade grades by player, 2017

For every player traded for in at least 10 redraft leagues in 2017: the useful points a week the team that got him won or lost, on average, and who he was most often traded for. Pick a player for his full trade history. Teams that traded for Todd Gurley won the most, +9.3 a week.

Quarterbacks

PlayerPoints a weekMost often traded for
Russell Wilson+3.8Derek CarrTom Brady
Cam Newton+2.9Matt RyanDrew Brees
Alex Smith+1.7Adam ThielenBen Roethlisberger
Tom Brady−1.6Drew BreesKirk Cousins
Carson Wentz+0.6Matt RyanBen Roethlisberger
Kirk Cousins+1.9Tom BradyMarcus Mariota
Matthew Stafford−1.0Tom BradyKirk Cousins
Philip Rivers+1.6Drew BreesKirk Cousins
Ben Roethlisberger+4.3Alex SmithDrew Brees
Dak Prescott+0.2Cam NewtonJameis Winston
Drew Brees−1.9Tom BradyCam Newton
Jared Goff+2.3–
Show all 40
PlayerPoints a weekMost often traded for
Blake Bortles+3.0–
Case Keenum+2.0–
Matt Ryan−2.2Cam NewtonDrew Brees
Marcus Mariota−1.5Kirk CousinsDrew Brees
Tyrod Taylor+1.2Carson Wentz
Andy Dalton−1.1Matt Ryan
Derek Carr−1.3Russell WilsonTom Brady
Jacoby Brissett−1.1–
Josh McCown+2.5–
Jameis Winston−0.1Dak PrescottTom Brady
Joe Flacco−1.0–
Eli Manning+0.6–
DeShone Kizer−0.3–
Deshaun Watson−0.8Julio Jones
Jay Cutler−0.1–
Trevor Siemian−3.0–
Aaron Rodgers−2.0–
Brett Hundley+2.4–
Mitchell Trubisky−1.2–
Carson Palmer−2.1–
Jimmy Garoppolo+0.4–
C.J. Beathard−2.8–
Brock Osweiler−1.5–
Brian Hoyer−2.2–
Mike Glennon––
Sam Bradford−2.8–
Teddy Bridgewater−3.6–
Andrew Luck−2.0–

Running backs

PlayerPoints a weekMost often traded for
Todd Gurley+9.3Le'Veon BellAntonio Brown
Le'Veon Bell+4.6Todd GurleyJulio Jones
Alvin Kamara+8.1Julio JonesJarvis Landry
Kareem Hunt+0.5Julio JonesMike Evans
Melvin Gordon+0.3Lamar MillerLeSean McCoy
Mark Ingram+5.9DeMarco MurrayDez Bryant
LeSean McCoy+2.0Julio JonesDeMarco Murray
Carlos Hyde−1.2Julio JonesAmari Cooper
Leonard Fournette−1.5Julio JonesLe'Veon Bell
Christian McCaffrey+0.6DeMarco MurrayA.J. Green
Duke Johnson−0.4–
Dion Lewis+3.4–
Show all 87
PlayerPoints a weekMost often traded for
Ezekiel Elliott−0.3Julio JonesDevonta Freeman
Jordan Howard+0.8Julio JonesDoug Martin
Devonta Freeman−1.6Mike EvansJulio Jones
Lamar Miller−1.2T.Y. HiltonMelvin Gordon
Jerick McKinnon−0.2Julio JonesMelvin Gordon
C.J. Anderson+0.3Jay AjayiLeSean McCoy
Frank Gore+0.1C.J. AndersonJay Ajayi
DeMarco Murray−0.1LeSean McCoyJay Ajayi
Alex Collins+2.2–
Tevin Coleman+0.2Tarik CohenJulio Jones
Javorius Allen−0.3Amari Cooper
Marshawn Lynch+0.3DeAndre HopkinsDeMarco Murray
Latavius Murray+1.2–
Theo Riddick+0.7–
Giovani Bernard+0.6–
Chris Thompson−1.4Amari CooperJulio Jones
Tarik Cohen−1.2Joe MixonAmari Cooper
Bilal Powell+0.1–
Jamaal Williams+3.1–
Isaiah Crowell−0.1Doug MartinDeMarco Murray
Kenyan Drake+3.6–
Joe Mixon−0.1Tarik CohenStefon Diggs
Orleans Darkwa−0.7–
Derrick Henry−0.2Drew Brees
James White−1.4Jarvis LandryJay Ajayi
Jay Ajayi−2.5Brandin CooksDeMarco Murray
Rex Burkhead+1.5–
Ameer Abdullah−1.1Jay AjayiMark Ingram
Matt Forte+0.2–
Jonathan Stewart+0.6–
LeGarrette Blount−1.4Jay AjayiDavante Adams
Samaje Perine+0.4–
Austin Ekeler−1.5–
Matt Breida−0.4–
Marlon Mack−1.4–
Wayne Gallman−1.5–
J.D. McKissic+0.8–
Rodney Smith+2.5–
Ty Montgomery−1.4Lamar Miller
Devontae Booker−1.6–
Andre Ellington−1.7–
T.J. Yeldon−1.7–
Shane Vereen−1.2–
DeAndre Washington−1.1–
Chris Ivory−1.4–
Jalen Richard−1.0–
Aaron Jones Sr.−1.9DeMarco Murray
Adrian Peterson−1.6Brandin CooksTyreek Hill
Doug Martin−2.4LeSean McCoyDeMarco Murray
Elijah McGuire−0.9–
Alfred Morris−1.1–
Charcandrick West−0.6–
Kerwynn Williams−1.1–
Mike Gillislee−2.1Kelvin BenjaminRob Gronkowski
Jamaal Charles−1.3–
Dalvin Cook−3.1Julio Jones
Damien Williams−1.1–
Danny Woodhead−1.7–
D'Onta Foreman−0.3–
Wendell Smallwood−1.0–
Jacquizz Rodgers−1.0–
Rob Kelley−0.8Terrelle Pryor
Chris Carson−1.7–
Thomas Rawls−1.5–
Eddie Lacy−0.9–
Terrance West−1.5–
Paul Perkins−0.8–
Chris Johnson−0.4–
Darren Sproles−1.7–
C.J. Prosise−1.7–
Jeremy Hill−1.9–
James Conner−1.5–
David Johnson−2.6Joe MixonTarik Cohen
Darren McFadden−1.7–
Spencer Ware−5.9–

Wide receivers

PlayerPoints a weekMost often traded for
DeAndre Hopkins+4.7Antonio BrownAmari Cooper
Antonio Brown+4.1Todd GurleyDez Bryant
Keenan Allen+4.4Julio JonesMike Evans
Larry Fitzgerald+2.8Carlos HydeJulio Jones
Michael Thomas+1.8Mike EvansA.J. Green
Jarvis Landry+1.2Doug MartinDeMarco Murray
Julio Jones+1.8Keenan AllenDez Bryant
Tyreek Hill+2.8Julio JonesBrandin Cooks
Adam Thielen+2.4Alex SmithKelvin Benjamin
Marvin Jones+3.1Stefon DiggsKeenan Allen
A.J. Green−0.7Amari CooperChristian McCaffrey
Golden Tate+0.2Julio JonesA.J. Green
Show all 95
PlayerPoints a weekMost often traded for
Doug Baldwin−0.3Amari CooperJay Ajayi
Davante Adams+3.5Amari CooperDeAndre Hopkins
Brandin Cooks+0.6Mike EvansJay Ajayi
Demaryius Thomas−0.2Julio JonesMike Evans
Mike Evans−1.7Brandin CooksDevonta Freeman
Robbie Chosen+3.2–
Stefon Diggs−0.7Julio JonesJoe Mixon
JuJu Smith-Schuster+1.1Antonio Brown
Alshon Jeffery+0.6Julio JonesDez Bryant
Nelson Agholor+2.5–
Dez Bryant−2.4Julio JonesMark Ingram
Cooper Kupp+1.8–
Jermaine Kearse+1.1–
Mohamed Sanu+0.9–
T.Y. Hilton+0.5Julio JonesLamar Miller
Michael Crabtree−0.6Antonio BrownDoug Martin
Kenny Stills+2.9–
Marquise Goodwin+2.2–
Robert Woods+1.2–
Ted Ginn+0.0–
Randall Cobb−2.2Julio JonesAmari Cooper
Amari Cooper+0.6A.J. GreenCarlos Hyde
Rishard Matthews+1.2–
Jamison Crowder+1.5–
Mike Wallace+1.0–
Paul Richardson−0.1–
Marqise Lee+0.6–
Sammy Watkins−0.3Amari CooperDez Bryant
Sterling Shepard+1.3–
DeSean Jackson−0.7Golden TateJulio Jones
Jordy Nelson−2.7Julio JonesJarvis Landry
Danny Amendola−0.9Amari CooperDeMarco Murray
Tyrell Williams−0.1–
Kelvin Benjamin−1.4Julio JonesAmari Cooper
Martavis Bryant−0.9Terrelle PryorDeMarco Murray
Travis Benjamin−2.7–
DeVante Parker−1.2Amari CooperDez Bryant
Adam Humphries+2.1–
Kendall Wright−1.0–
Tyler Lockett+1.2–
Brandon LaFell+0.8–
Josh Doctson+0.0–
Eric Decker−0.6–
Emmanuel Sanders−5.3A.J. GreenAmari Cooper
William Fuller−1.1Amari CooperBrandin Cooks
Terrance Williams−1.3–
Chris Hogan−2.0Julio JonesMark Ingram
Jaron Brown−1.1–
Jeremy Maclin−1.1Terrelle Pryor
Allen Hurns−1.2–
Kenny Golladay−1.5–
J.J. Nelson−1.3–
Cole Beasley−0.8–
Torrey Smith−2.8–
Pierre Garcon−1.7Dez BryantKelvin Benjamin
Roger Lewis−1.0–
Bennie Fowler−3.3–
Taylor Gabriel−0.6–
Donte Moncrief−1.5–
Odell Beckham Jr.−5.5Jay AjayiRob Gronkowski
Brandon Coleman−2.0–
Zay Jones−0.7–
John Brown−0.4–
Corey Davis−1.4–
Rashard Higgins−0.9–
Dede Westbrook−0.1–
Corey Coleman−0.7–
Dontrelle Inman−2.6–
Kenny Britt−1.2–
Josh Gordon−0.9–
Terrelle Pryor−1.8Martavis BryantAmari Cooper
Geronimo Allison−0.3–
Tavon Austin−1.0–
Brandon Marshall−1.6–
Curtis Samuel−1.9–
Mike Williams−0.7–
Breshad Perriman+0.6–
Willie Snead−1.5–
Allen Robinson−3.8–
Kevin White−0.4–
John Ross−0.8–
Julian Edelman−1.5–
Cameron Meredith−1.0–

Tight ends

PlayerPoints a weekMost often traded for
Travis Kelce+2.5Jimmy GrahamDelanie Walker
Rob Gronkowski+2.9Zach ErtzKyle Rudolph
Zach Ertz+1.0Rob GronkowskiJimmy Graham
Devin Funchess+0.6Brandin CooksAmari Cooper
Evan Engram+1.5Travis KelceRob Gronkowski
Delanie Walker+0.7Travis KelceJordan Reed
Jimmy Graham+1.2Travis KelceRob Gronkowski
Jack Doyle0.0–
Kyle Rudolph+0.5Rob GronkowskiTravis Kelce
Jason Witten−0.9Rob GronkowskiEvan Engram
Cameron Brate+9.1Rob Gronkowski
Benjamin Watson+0.1–
Show all 36
PlayerPoints a weekMost often traded for
Jared Cook−3.3–
Eric Ebron+0.8–
Hunter Henry+0.1Rob Gronkowski
Tyler Kroft−0.1–
Vernon Davis−0.1–
Austin Hooper−0.7–
Charles Clay−19.1–
George Kittle−0.3–
Austin Seferian-Jenkins−1.7–
O.J. Howard+0.3–
Jesse James−0.2–
Julius Thomas−0.7–
David Njoku+0.1–
Ed Dickson−2.4–
Antonio Gates+2.3–
Coby Fleener−1.2–
Jordan Reed−1.5Delanie WalkerRob Gronkowski
Martellus Bennett−2.3Rob Gronkowski
Jordan Matthews−2.3–
Zach Miller−1.4–
Greg Olsen−0.2Rob Gronkowski
C.J. Fiedorowicz−2.6–
Dwayne Allen−0.3–
Tyler Eifert+2.4–

Common questions

Which 2017 fantasy trades worked out best?

In 2017, teams that traded for Todd Gurley won the most: +9.3 useful points a week on average.

How are these trades graded?

Each trade is graded from what both teams received: the useful points a week those players scored for their new team over the rest of the season, above a typical starter at their position that week. A trade is even when the two sides finished close, and a clear edge when one side came out well ahead. Draft picks count at the usual value of a pick at that spot. Redraft leagues only.

Where do these trades come from?

From real redraft leagues connected to Fantasy Hall of Fame from Yahoo, Sleeper, ESPN, CBS, MFL, Fleaflicker and Fantrax. A player, trade partner or trade shows only when it covers at least 10 leagues, and no league or manager is identified.