Caleb Williams or Tyler Shough?

By Fantasy Hall of Fame · Data as of November 12, 2026

In week 6, 1,766 real fantasy leagues had a team with both Caleb Williams and Tyler Shough that started one of them. 65% started Caleb Williams. Tyler Shough scored 27.0 to Caleb Williams's 16.5, so the 35% who started him got it right. Week 10: Caleb Williams is on a bye in week 10; Tyler Shough faces CAR, which has allowed 16.5 PPR points a game to QBs since week 3 (20th most of 32).

Player	Week 10 matchup	Started, week 6	Points a week	Last 3 games	Value
Caleb Williams CHI	Bye	65%	19.2	22.1, 14.0, 16.8	15
Tyler Shough NO	vs CAR 16.5 a game to QBs, 20th most	35%	19.0	27.0, 14.8, 19.7	7

Tyler Shough has outscored Caleb Williams in 3 of 5 weeks both played this season. Real leagues' rest-of-season values: Caleb Williams 15, Tyler Shough 7.

Every week managers chose between them

Week by week

A call: a team with both players at the same position on its roster, both of whom played that week, that started one and benched the other. Leagues: the leagues where a team made that call; a week's list shows calls at least 100 leagues made, with at least 15% going the other way. Calls come from Yahoo, Sleeper and ESPN leagues. Points are PPR. Matchup: the PPR points a game his week 10 opponent has allowed to his position since week 3, ranked across the league. Value: real leagues' rest-of-season Trade Values, the median across leagues, with the top player at 100 (see the rankings).

More calls at every position on the week 10 start/sit page.